Shropshire Council to dispose of Whitchurch Civic Centre

Whitchurch Civic Centre. Picture: Shropshire Council
Whitchurch Civic Centre. Picture: Shropshire Council
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Shropshire Council's finance chief has said it will be "difficult" for a community group to take on Whitchurch Civic Centre as the authority backed the sale of the stricken building.

Creative Whitchurch, which is being set up as a charitable incorporated organisation, has drawn up proposals for a possible new future use for the town centre site.

Most of the Civic Centre in High Street has been closed since September 2023 after the discovery of reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete alongside wider structural concerns.

Shropshire Council said it cannot afford the £4 million required to upgrade the building. At a meeting on Wednesday (September 9), Cabinet members voted to dispose of it due to its dire financial situation.

“We’re not selling it, we’re disposing of it because we’re recognising the need, how it’s viewed by the residents, and its position within Whitchurch Town Centre,” said Councillor Roger Evans, portfolio holder for finance.

“These are one of the hard decisions we don’t want to make, but must make due to the financial position the council is in.

“The council has no money. It is borrowing money so it can fulfil all its legal obligations. The estimate at present is we will need just under £100 million to balance the books for this year.

“This will cost the council taxpayer around £9 million per year in interest and repayment charges for the next 20 years, or a little less if the loan is over 40 years.

“When we took over the council, we knew the financial situation was bad, but only later as that year unfolded did we learn the true extent of the financial mess the council was in. Many promises had been made, but no cash has ever been identified in how they could be met.

“The building, even though closed, is costing the council money, and this will increase as time passes. A solution needs to be found.”

Councillor Dan Thomas (Conservative, Much Wenlock) asked, if a fully funded and deliverable community-led proposal was to emerge, what level of flexibility would the council be prepared to show before any financial disposal decision is concluded.

Duncan Whitfield, the Section 151 officer who oversees all of the council’s finances, said it will be a struggle for any community group to raise the sort of resources that are necessary to fund a redevelopment, plus the maintenance costs to manage it.

“The income it generates could prove a revenue challenge for the council or a community group moving forward,” said Mr Whitfield.

“We don’t know until we see what the proposals are, but the optics from a government point of view will be, if they see a building which is capable of generating some kind a receipt for us and we choose to take another option that generates no receipt and potentially generates costs going forward, when they meet with the chief exec and myself in a few months, they will probably be asking, why did we do that? And that puts us at risk.”

Kassandra Polyzoides, interim service director for place shaping, added that it depends what Councillor Thomas means by “flexible”.

“The whole idea of taking it through the next due diligence is to get some certainty around what the deliverable and funded options are,” she said.

“So, if flexibility is around how the council could support that from an officer perspective, that’s one way in which we would be willing to do that.

“Indeed, we are having discussions, as are Cabinet and others, with the community quickly to determine what those proposals might be.

“If the flexibility is around a financial commitment, that’s a completely different discussion. And it will be difficult to determine what that would be unless we see what the proposals are in detail that are coming forward to us.”

The recommendation to dispose of the building was unanimously approved. Councillor Andy Hall – who represents Whitchurch North and has been heavily involved in the campaign to save the Civic Centre – left the room during the discussion and did not vote.

He has called a public meeting for this Friday (September 11) at 7pm in the Sports/Market Hall to discuss the situation going forward.

Councillor Heather Kidd, the leader of Shropshire Council, is due to attend along with Whitchurch ward councillors, Shropshire Council officers, and Save Our Civic representatives.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos