'Systemic failures' at Shrewsbury Hospital in Wem man's death

Multiple failures were found in weeks before  the death of Trevor Collins from Wem <i>(Image: Sarah Bentley)</i>
Multiple failures were found in weeks before the death of Trevor Collins from Wem (Image: Sarah Bentley)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Senior figures at Shrewsbury Hospital have admitted to “systemic failures” after a Wem man died from complications caused by severe constipation.

Senior doctors admitted in a hearing at Shrewsbury Coroner’s Court today (May 1) that there were a series of errors before the death of Trevor Collins in May 2022.

Mr Collins was described as a man who “lit up the room” and a talented musician by his family, even writing a song for the NHS during the Covid pandemic.

A post-mortem found Mr Collins had an obstruction several feet long up to his small bowel and a “grossly distended stomach” which contained two litres of matter.


RECOMMENDED READING:


It was heard he also did not have a normal bowel movement for eight weeks, but that this was not fully picked up by physicians.

He also had aspiration pneumonia which was caused by the stomach contents entering his lungs.

Dr Johnathan Jones, Executive Medical Director at SATH, apologised to Mr Collins’ family and told the court that an internal investigation found “key omissions in care” and that his “death may have been preventable”.

Particularly it focused on the lack of a nasal gastric (NG) tube being regularly given to Mr Collins who was being violently sick in the weeks before his death – leading to the aspiration pneumonia.

It was heard that when in one of only two occasions a tube was inserted into Mr Collins overnight, over half a litre of fluid was drained from his stomach.

Dr Jones said it was “not clear” why another tube was not put in and that it was one of a number issues found that showed a “lack of leadership”.


What happens at an inquest and what can the press report?

Reporting on inquests is one of the most difficult jobs faced by any journalist, but there are important reasons why local newspapers attend coroner’s court hearings and report on proceedings.

Here we will try and answer some of your questions about what will happen, what can be reported and why.


Dr Graham Heyes, who was involved in authoring a serious incident report at the trust also apologised on behalf of the trust and said the “shortcomings were systemic”.

He said there had been “missed opportunities” with a lack of stool charts, a “lack of ownership by a (medical) team” leaving Mr Collins “a persistent feeling he was waiting for another team”.

Dr Heyes said that this may have been helped if there had been more communication with the family as it may avoided confirmation bias

“We know that a patient’s family are a really great way of making people requestion the concepts we may have built up on one day as that is more information that may be brought,” said Dr Heyes.


Help support trusted local news

Sign up for a digital subscription now: www.whitchurchherald.co.uk/subscribe/

As a digital subscriber you will get

  • Unlimited access to the Whitchurch Herald website
  • Advert-light access
  • Reader rewards

Mr Collin’s daughter Sarah Bentley told the court her father’s treatment had been a “travesty”.

“I believe my dad’s case is exceptional but not complex,” said Mrs Bentley.

She accused the trust of “denial, deflection and delay” and that a GDPR request had revealed communications which said: “Tell the eldest daughter we don’t want to waste anyone’s time on this.”

Mrs Bentley said she had fought for three years to get the case to court and that her father had been “dreadfully neglected”.

Assistant coroner Heath Westerman praised the work of Mrs Bentley and said “I salute your bravery - I think you should be proud of what you have done on behalf of your dad”

Mrs Bentley asked Mr Westerman to issue a Section 28, Prevention of future deaths’ order which would give recommendations for changes to practices at the Trust.

The legal team for the Trust argued against this and pointed to a series of new electronic systems introduced for stool monitoring on wards which they argue would avoid another similar case.

Mr Westerman will issue a verdict in the coming weeks.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos